Unit 1 · Topic 1.4 Beta

Reference Frames and Relative Motion

Every velocity is measured relative to a reference frame.

Practice 2: Mathematical RoutinesPractice 3: Scientific Questioning and Argumentation

Question set for this topic

Part 1 · Hook

Why this matters

Sit still on a plane cruising at 250 m/s and the drink on your tray does not move. To someone on the ground, you and the drink are crossing the sky at about 900 km/h. Neither of you is wrong. A velocity is always measured by someone, and different observers get different numbers.

Part 2 · Before you start

What this builds on

Part 3 · Prerequisite check

Quick check before you start

1. Taking east as positive, which is the velocity of a car moving west at 15 m/s?

  1. −15 m/s
  2. +15 m/s
  3. 0 m/s
  4. +30 m/s
Show the answer

West is the negative direction.

  • Correct: −15 m/s:
  • +15 m/s:
  • 0 m/s:
  • +30 m/s:

2. What is the vector sum of +4.0 m/s and −1.5 m/s along a line?

  1. +2.5 m/s
  2. +5.5 m/s
  3. −5.5 m/s
  4. −2.5 m/s
Show the answer

Add the signed values: 4.0 − 1.5 = +2.5 m/s.

  • Correct: +2.5 m/s:
  • +5.5 m/s:
  • −5.5 m/s:
  • −2.5 m/s:

3. A cart's velocity goes from 2.0 to 3.0 m/s in 2.0 s. What is its acceleration?

  1. 0.50 m/s²
  2. 1.0 m/s²
  3. 2.5 m/s²
  4. 2.0 m/s²
Show the answer

a = Δv/Δt = 1.0 ÷ 2.0.

  • Correct: 0.50 m/s²:
  • 1.0 m/s²:
  • 2.5 m/s²:
  • 2.0 m/s²:

Part 4 · See it

See it first

A train moves to the right at +20.0 m/s relative to the ground. Inside, a passenger walks toward the front at +1.5 m/s relative to the train. An observer stands on the platform. The walker's velocity relative to the ground is 1.5 m/s + 20.0 m/s = +21.5 m/s; walking toward the back at 1.5 m/s would give +18.5 m/s.
A passenger's velocity relative to the ground is her velocity relative to the train plus the train's velocity relative to the ground. LevlPrep original diagram.

Part 5 · Step by step

How it works, step by step

  1. Two observers move relative to each otherthey measure different velocities for the same object
  2. The object moves at v relative to a frame that moves at V relative to the groundits velocity relative to the ground is v + V (signed, along one line)
  3. You swap which observer is measuringthe relative velocity flips sign: if B moves at +3 m/s relative to A, A moves at −3 m/s relative to B
  4. The two frames move at a constant velocity relative to each otherthe same velocity is added at every instant, so both measure the same acceleration

Part 6 · Key ideas

Key ideas

  • A reference frame is the observer's point of view, with a coordinate system that moves with the observer. "At rest" means at rest relative to some frame.
  • Relative velocity along a line: v(object, ground) = v(object, frame) + v(frame, ground). Give each velocity its sign.
  • To find a velocity relative to a moving observer, subtract the observer's velocity: v(A, B) = v(A, ground) − v(B, ground).
  • Frames moving at a constant velocity relative to each other measure the same acceleration, because the added velocity cancels in Δv.

Part 7 · Misconception

A common mistake

The wrong idea: The train's velocity only matters to people on the platform; a passenger walking in the aisle has her own speed of 1.5 m/s, period.

What actually happens: Her velocity depends on who measures it: 1.5 m/s relative to the train, 21.5 m/s relative to the ground when the train moves at 20.0 m/s. Every velocity needs a frame, and the frames are linked by adding velocities.

Part 8 · Check yourself

Check yourself

Exam-style questions. Anything you miss goes into your review queue.

Diagram

A moving walkway at an airport

An airport walkway 48 m long moves to the right at 1.2 m/s relative to the floor. Ana walks to the right on it at 1.8 m/s relative to the walkway. Ben stands still on the walkway. Cara stands on the floor beside it. Right is positive.

walkway: 1.2 m/s to the rightAna1.8 m/s relative to the walkwayBenstands still onthe walkwayCarafloor

Key: orange arrow, the walkway's velocity relative to the floor; gold arrow, Ana's velocity relative to the walkway. Arrow lengths are to scale.

1. What is Ana's velocity relative to the floor, as Cara measures it?

Type a number in m/s.

Show the answer

Velocity relative to the floor = velocity relative to the walkway + velocity of the walkway relative to the floor = 1.8 m/s + 1.2 m/s = +3.0 m/s.

  • Answer: 3.0 m/s

2. What is Ana's velocity as Ben measures it?

  1. +3.0 m/s
  2. +1.2 m/s
  3. Zero, because they are both on the walkway
  4. +1.8 m/s
Show the answer

Ben is at rest relative to the walkway, so in his frame Ana moves at her walking velocity, +1.8 m/s.

  • +3.0 m/s: That is her velocity relative to the floor. Ben is moving with the walkway, not standing on the floor.
  • +1.2 m/s: That is the walkway's velocity relative to the floor, which Ben shares.
  • Zero, because they are both on the walkway: Ben stands still on the walkway while Ana walks on it, so she moves away from him.
  • Correct: +1.8 m/s: Right: Ben moves with the walkway, so he sees only her motion relative to the walkway.

3. What is Cara's velocity as Ben measures it?

  1. +1.2 m/s
  2. Zero, because Cara is standing still
  3. −1.2 m/s
  4. −3.0 m/s
Show the answer

If B moves at +1.2 m/s relative to C, then C moves at −1.2 m/s relative to B. Swapping the observer flips the sign.

  • +1.2 m/s: From Ben's frame, Cara moves the opposite way to how he moves relative to her.
  • Zero, because Cara is standing still: Cara is at rest relative to the floor, not relative to Ben.
  • Correct: −1.2 m/s: Right: Ben moves right at 1.2 m/s relative to the floor, so to him the floor and Cara move left at 1.2 m/s.
  • −3.0 m/s: That would be relative to Ana. Ben moves only with the walkway, at 1.2 m/s.

Data table

Three vehicles on a straight highway

A truck, a car and a motorcycle travel along a straight highway. East is positive. The table gives each one's velocity relative to the road.

Velocities relative to the road
VehicleVelocity relative to the road (m/s)
Truck+22
Car+29
Motorcycle−17

4. What is the car's velocity relative to the truck?

Type a number in m/s.

Show the answer

v(car, truck) = v(car, road) − v(truck, road) = 29 m/s − 22 m/s = +7.0 m/s. From the truck, the car pulls ahead eastward.

  • Answer: 7.0 m/s

5. What is the motorcycle's velocity relative to the truck?

Type a number in m/s.

Show the answer

v(moto, truck) = v(moto, road) − v(truck, road) = −17 m/s − 22 m/s = −39 m/s. From the truck, the oncoming motorcycle approaches at 39 m/s.

  • Answer: -39 m/s

6. You sit in a train at rest in a station and see the train beside yours start to move forward. A moment later you realize it is your own train moving backward. Why could you not tell at first?

  1. Your train was moving too slowly to have a velocity
  2. The other train had a larger velocity than yours
  3. Motion is visible to a person on the ground, not to a passenger
  4. You saw relative motion, and either train moving looks the same
Show the answer

A velocity is measured relative to a reference frame. Seeing only the other train, you measure its velocity relative to your train, which is the same whichever train moves.

  • Your train was moving too slowly to have a velocity: Any motion is a velocity; the issue is which frame you measure it in.
  • The other train had a larger velocity than yours: Neither velocity was larger in a way you could see; you saw only how they moved relative to each other.
  • Motion is visible to a person on the ground, not to a passenger: Any observer can measure motion; each measures it relative to their own frame.
  • Correct: You saw relative motion, and either train moving looks the same: Right: from your seat, you can only see the other train's motion relative to yours.

Part 9 · Summary

Summary

Every velocity is measured relative to a reference frame. Along a line, a velocity relative to the ground is the velocity relative to a moving frame plus that frame's velocity; swapping observers flips the sign. Frames moving at constant velocity relative to each other agree on accelerations.

Part 10 · Up next

What comes next

Part 11 · Connections

Connections