Unit 3 · Topic 3.1 Beta

Generalist and Specialist Species

Specialist species have narrow niches: a few foods, one habitat or a narrow range of conditions.

Practice 1: Concept Explanation

Part 1 · Hook

Why this matters

A giant panda spends most of its day eating bamboo, which makes up nearly all of its diet. A raccoon a few continents away eats fruit, frogs, insects, eggs and whatever is in a city trash can. When a bamboo forest flowers and dies back, which happens every few decades, the panda is in trouble. When a forest is cleared for a suburb, the raccoon often does better than before.

Part 2 · Before you start

What this builds on

Part 3 · Prerequisite check

Quick check before you start

1. What is a species’ niche?

  1. Its role and the full set of conditions and resources it uses
  2. The place where it sleeps
  3. The number of individuals in its population
  4. The name of its habitat
Show the answer

A niche is how a species lives: what it eats, where and when it is active, the conditions it needs.

  • Correct: Its role and the full set of conditions and resources it uses:
  • The place where it sleeps:
  • The number of individuals in its population:
  • The name of its habitat:

2. A species survives only between 20 and 24 °C. How would you describe its range of tolerance for temperature?

  1. Narrow
  2. Wide
  3. Optimal
  4. Unlimited
Show the answer

A four-degree band is a narrow range of tolerance.

  • Correct: Narrow:
  • Wide:
  • Optimal:
  • Unlimited:

Part 4 · See it

See it first

Two curves of how much of each food size two species eat. The specialist curve is tall and narrow, centered on 6 mm food items. The generalist curve is low and broad, spread from about 0 to 20 mm. Invented example.
A specialist eats a narrow range of food sizes; a generalist eats a broad range. Invented example. LevlPrep original diagram.

Part 5 · Step by step

How it works, step by step

  1. A specialist depends on a narrow set of foods, habitats or conditionsit can be very efficient where those resources are plentiful
  2. The environment changes and its one key resource declinesthe specialist has nothing to switch to, so its population falls
  3. A generalist uses many foods, habitats and conditionswhen one resource declines it switches to others, so it copes better with change

Part 6 · Key ideas

Key ideas

  • Specialist species have a narrow niche: they eat a few foods, live in one kind of habitat, or tolerate a narrow range of conditions. Examples: the giant panda (bamboo) and the koala (eucalyptus leaves).
  • Generalist species have a broad niche: they eat many foods, live in many habitats and tolerate a wide range of conditions. Examples: raccoons, coyotes, rats and cockroaches.
  • Specialists do well in stable environments where their resource is reliable. They are more likely to decline or die out when the environment changes.
  • Generalists cope better with change, and they often spread into new places, including towns and farms.

Part 7 · Misconception

A common mistake

The wrong idea: Generalists are always better off than specialists.

What actually happens: Specialists are often more efficient at using their one resource, so they can outcompete generalists where that resource is plentiful and stable. Generalists win when conditions change.

Part 8 · Check yourself

Check yourself

Exam-style questions. Anything you miss goes into your review queue.

Data

Two bird species before and after a forest is cleared

Number of breeding pairs in a 10 km² study area before and after most of its old forest was cleared for farms and houses (invented data for practice)
SpeciesFoods eatenNesting sites usedPairs before clearingPairs after clearing
Woodpecker Winsects in dead treesholes in large dead trees406
Bird Xinsects, seeds, fruit, scrapstrees, shrubs, buildings5065

1. Based on the table, which statement correctly classifies the two birds?

  1. W is a specialist and X is a generalist
  2. W is a generalist and X is a specialist
  3. Both are specialists, because both eat insects
  4. Both are generalists, because both live in forests
Show the answer

Classify by how many foods, habitats and conditions a species can use.

  • Correct: W is a specialist and X is a generalist: Right: W uses one food and one nesting site; X uses many of each.
  • W is a generalist and X is a specialist: W eats one food type and nests in one kind of site, which is a narrow niche.
  • Both are specialists, because both eat insects: Bird X also eats seeds, fruit and scraps, a broad diet.
  • Both are generalists, because both live in forests: Living in a forest does not make a species a generalist; the range of resources it uses does.

2. Write the setup for the percent change in breeding pairs of woodpecker W after the clearing, then give the answer.

Type the setup as on the exam, with brackets and units, then the answer.

Show the answer

Start at 40 pairs: 6−4040×100=−85%\frac{6 - 40}{40} \times 100 = -85\%.

  • Setup: 6−4040⋅100\frac{6 - 40}{40} \cdot 100; answer -85 %

3. Which explanation best accounts for the change in woodpecker W?

  1. Bird X ate most of the woodpecker’s eggs after clearing
  2. Clearing removed the large dead trees it needs for both food and nests
  3. The woodpecker moved to the new houses and was not counted
  4. The woodpecker began eating seeds and scraps instead
Show the answer

A specialist declines when the one resource it depends on is removed.

  • Bird X ate most of the woodpecker’s eggs after clearing: Nothing in the data shows predation by bird X.
  • Correct: Clearing removed the large dead trees it needs for both food and nests: Right: as a specialist, W had no other food or nest site to switch to.
  • The woodpecker moved to the new houses and was not counted: W nests only in holes in large dead trees, not in buildings.
  • The woodpecker began eating seeds and scraps instead: If it had switched foods, it would have done better, not worse.

4. By how many breeding pairs did bird X increase after the clearing?

Type a number, then its unit (pairs). Scale words (2.5 million) and powers of ten (2.5 × 10^6) are read.

Show the answer

Subtract: 65−50=1565 - 50 = 15 pairs.

  • Answer: 15 pairs

Model or diagram

Food sizes eaten by two species

Two curves of how much of each food size two species eat. The specialist curve is tall and narrow, centered on 6 mm food items. The generalist curve is low and broad, spread from about 0 to 20 mm. Invented example.
LevlPrep original diagram.

5. Where 6 mm seeds are plentiful year after year, the specialist is more common than the generalist. Which explanation fits best?

  1. It handles 6 mm seeds more efficiently than the generalist
  2. The generalist is unable to eat 6 mm seeds
  3. Specialists have more offspring in each generation
  4. Generalists avoid areas where seeds are common
Show the answer

Specialists can win where conditions are stable and their resource is abundant.

  • Correct: It handles 6 mm seeds more efficiently than the generalist: Right: specializing often means being better at one task, which pays off when that resource is reliable.
  • The generalist is unable to eat 6 mm seeds: The generalist’s curve includes 6 mm food.
  • Specialists have more offspring in each generation: The figure shows food use, not number of offspring.
  • Generalists avoid areas where seeds are common: Nothing in the figure suggests that.

6. Why are specialist species more likely than generalists to decline when a habitat changes?

  1. They reproduce faster and use up their food
  2. They are smaller and weaker than most generalists
  3. They rely on few resources, with little to switch to
  4. They are eaten by generalists in disturbed areas
Show the answer

A narrow niche means fewer options when conditions change.

  • They reproduce faster and use up their food: How fast they reproduce is not what makes a species a specialist.
  • They are smaller and weaker than most generalists: Body size does not define a specialist; pandas are large.
  • Correct: They rely on few resources, with little to switch to: Right: if their resource declines, they have no fallback.
  • They are eaten by generalists in disturbed areas: Predation can happen, but the main reason is their narrow niche.

Part 9 · Summary

Summary

Specialist species have narrow niches: a few foods, one habitat or a narrow range of conditions. They thrive where their resource is stable but decline when the environment changes. Generalist species have broad niches and can switch foods and habitats, so they cope better with change and often spread into new and disturbed places.

Part 10 · Up next

What comes next

Part 11 · Connections

Connections

Share to Google Classroom (opens in a new tab)

Question set for this topic